Guest Blogger Scott Eder on Urban Fantasy vs Contemporary Fantasy

 Genre Confusion (Doh!) – Urban VS. Contemporary Fantasy

By Scott Eder

Hello. My name is Scott, and I write Urban Fantasy. Wait, no, that’s what I did a few weeks ago, before the revelation, before DragonCon. Today, in my post-DC era, I write Contemporary Fantasy. And the funny thing is that I haven’t changed a thing. I still write the same novels, but my genre perception has shifted thanks to the wisdom presented at Dragon*Con.

I’ve heard the advice not to worry about genre. Let an agent or editor figure out into which Fantasy subgenre the book should fall since the writer is not typically the best judge. That’s all well and good after the fact, once the book is sold and the decisions on how to market it are made. What about when a writer is discussing his work with publishing professionals or other authors?

When talking about my book, framing it in terms of genre is a natural thing. It’s meant to set a certain expectation or set of rules in which the plot unfolds and the characters develop. So, when talking about my book, Knight of Flame, I start off by telling people it’s Urban Fantasy with strong romantic elements. Here’s the kicker…I was wrong.

But, Scott, say it aint so. I wish I could. I feel kinda silly about it, actually. Thank goodness I came to the realization myself instead of having someone have to point it out to me. I don’t claim to know a lot about this industry into which I’m trying hard to break into. In fact, I know fairly little. That’s why I keep asking questions, hanging with those who do know about this crazy business, and attending different cons and seminars. Look out World Fantasy, you’re next.

I got my first inkling of my genre faux pas early on. I’d been trying to identify my niche, my stand-out factor. What made my Urban Fantasy novel unique? I realized that one of the differences is POV. My novel has multiple POVs. I haven’t seen that much in UF. Most UF stories turn upon the axis of a single driving character—typically a badass detective or bounty hunter protecting their slice of the world from the nefarious creatures of the night.

I was good with the multiple POV thing. I started talking that up and building my case on how my book differed from the others. That went well until I started asking questions of NYT bestselling UF authors about it and got some strange looks. Perhaps there’s a reason there isn’t much multiple POV in UF.

It seems that the general consensus about UF is that the pacing is very fast. That single POV ass-kicker drives through the story at a very fast pace. The characters don’t typically amble about smelling the flowers. They find and fight the badies threatening their town. The tone is dark and gritty, like the dirty streets and water of the cityscape in which they prowl. UF is the noire of the Fantasy genre.

And that’s where it all went crazy. Yeah, I see the dark and the grit and the detective aspect of UF stories. Mine decidedly did not have those elements. I realized the only things my novel and UF had in common was that it occurred in a city (for a little while) and brought magical elements into a real-world setting.

Sorry, but that’s just not enough. So, Knight of Flame is not Urban Fantasy. It’s Contemporary or Modern Fantasy. It doesn’t have the grit and dark tones of a Faith Hunter, Jim Butcher, or Kim Harrison novel. It’s more like the sense of wonder and camaraderie of the Companions of the Hall from R.A. Salvatore’s Forgotten Realms books. I loved the interplay between Drizzt, King Bruenor, Wulfgar, Regis, and Cattie-brie. They fed off each other while they saved the world from utter destruction time and again. I wanted to make sure that my characters had that type of relationship and wrote that in from the beginning. Duh. I should have realized.

The book held true to genre, but the writer got lost somewhere along the way.

That’s not the only place I got lost. This being my first trip to Dragon*Con, I spent a fair amount of time wandering the floors of the Hyatt and the Marriott. When I did find the right room at the right time, I learned and I’ll be passing some of those other lessons on in the coming weeks. Stay tuned.

Have fun,

Against the Shadow, burns a noble light.

Author Bio:

Since he was a kid, Scott wanted to be an author. Through the years, fantastic tales of nobility and strife, honor and chaos dominated his thoughts. After twenty years mired in the corporate machine, he broke free to bring those stories to life.

Scott lives with his wife and two children on the west coast of Florida.

Knight of Flame

Knight of Flame

Fire. The most chaotic of the primal elements. When wielded properly by the Knight of Flame, it burns like the sun. Otherwise, it slowly consumes the Knight, burning away his control, driving him towards dark deeds.

Stationed in Tampa, FL, Develor Quinteele, sixth Knight of Flame, waits impatiently for the predicted emergence of the last Gray Lord, his Order’s ancient enemy. Hampered by a centuries-old tragedy, Dev knows of only one way to control his elemental power—rage. It broils just below his surface, waiting for the slightest provocation to set it alight.

After a brutal attack by the Gray Lord’s minions for which Dev is blamed, he’s stripped of his freedom until he learns to control his violent impulses. With the help of his fellow Knights, can he balance his rage and unlock his true elemental potential to prevent Tampa’s devastation?

“In Knight of Flame Scott re-imagines traditional fantasy and forges something new from old metal—a fast-paced thriller that delivers a healthy dose of wonder. As enjoyable as it is engrossing.” ~ David Farland, International Best-Selling Author

Link to First Five Chapters:

Buy Links:



Contact Links:


Twitter: @Scotteder



Posted in Guest Bloggers and tagged , , , .


  1. I know your pain–it took me a while to figure out that I write contemporary fantasy, too! In my case I’ve got the first-person, fast-paced, modern-set elements… but these days urban fantasy really does have the connotation of fantasy noire. No detectives, no vampires, no shifters or mummies or crime-solving here. Just a woman, her twin, and her neighbor on a mission to burst the bubble of magic engulfing the American South, and hopefully free their families… if they don’t become forever trapped, too, that is.

    Also, I’m terribly envious you got to go to DragonCon! Can’t wait to go again myself.

  2. Hi Rebekkah,

    I’ll make a little space for you under the contemporary fantasy umbrella. I like the concept of your story. Good luck with it. Maybe I’ll see you at DragonCon next year.

    Have fun,

Comments are closed.